Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Claude Schryer's avatar

This is a brilliant! Many thanks. I will follow with great interest and open ears.

Expand full comment
Aaron Edgcomb's avatar

Tanya,

I meant to write a comment back when I first read this, but time dissipates .... I am looking forward to catching up with your newsletters shortly.

I wanted to say thanks for your efforts, I am so glad to have such a thoughtful place to go to consider music's relevance to social issues.

For a long while I have been thinking about music's ability to have social impact. The political message of many punk bands was fundamental to my early engagement with music. This has lead me to consider that music can only be "political" in one of two ways: either by explicitly stating social or political positions, or by existing in a larger context with positions stated either as commentary/critique or through practice I.e. communal living or somehow nourishing a subculture. I think about how the communities I engage with do or do not do make statements, or to what degree they follow through with them - one major example being in inherently abstract improvised music.

Just thoughts - trying to let them guide my actions in the future, and looking forward to your newsletter as a resource!

Expand full comment
8 more comments...

No posts